In the field of sport psychology, optimising performance often goes hand-in-hand with prioritising mental health and wellbeing. Among athletes, issues related to eating behaviours can pose significant challenges, particularly when distinguishing between disordered eating and clinically diagnosed eating disorders. While these terms are related, they describe different issues that require tailored responses.
Understanding the nuances between these behaviours is essential for athletes, coaches, and support professionals, as both can have profound effects on physical performance and psychological health.
Common Features: What Disordered Eating and Eating Disorders Share
Both disordered eating and eating disorders involve unhealthy eating patterns and behaviours that can disrupt an individual’s health, performance, and quality of life. These behaviours might include:
Restricting food intake or adhering to extreme dieting practices.
Skipping meals, fasting, or consuming very limited food groups.
Using laxatives, diuretics, or inducing vomiting to control weight.
Overexercising to "burn off" consumed calories.
At the core of these behaviours are often distorted attitudes toward food, weight, and body image. These patterns can lead to varying degrees of psychological distress and interfere with an individual’s ability to function, whether on the sporting field, in training, or in daily life.
Key Differences: Diagnosis, Severity, and Impact
1. Diagnostic Criteria
The primary distinction between disordered eating and eating disorders lies in clinical diagnosis. Eating disorders are medical conditions defined by specific diagnostic criteria, such as those outlined in the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders). Examples include anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and binge-eating disorder.
Disordered eating, however, encompasses a range of unhealthy eating behaviours that do not meet these clinical thresholds. These behaviours may be sporadic, less consistent, or less severe, which can make them harder to identify and address.
2. Severity and Persistence
Eating disorders involve persistent and severe symptoms. For example, a diagnosis of bulimia nervosa requires binge-eating and compensatory behaviours (e.g., vomiting or misuse of laxatives) to occur at least once a week for three months. Disordered eating might involve similar behaviours but at a lower frequency or intensity.
3. Functional Impairment and Psychological Distress
Individuals with eating disorders typically experience high levels of functional impairment and distress, which can manifest as:
Physical health complications: Weight changes, nutritional deficiencies, or other medical issues.
Mental health challenges: Anxiety, depression, and a preoccupation with food or weight.
Interpersonal difficulties: Struggles with relationships due to the impact of their eating behaviours.
Disordered eating, while concerning, often causes less disruption to daily life but can still undermine an individual’s wellbeing and performance if left unchecked.
Why This Matters in Sport
Athletes are often at increased risk of developing disordered eating or eating disorders due to the pressures associated with their sport. Whether it’s striving for a certain body composition, meeting weight requirements, or adhering to aesthetic ideals, the sporting environment can contribute to unhealthy attitudes and behaviours around food.
Risk Factors Across Sports
Performance Pressures: Athletes may believe that being lighter or leaner will enhance their performance, leading to restrictive eating or overexercising.
Aesthetic Demands: In sports that emphasise appearance, such as gymnastics or dance, there is often a cultural pressure to conform to specific body standards.
Weight-Specific Requirements: Sports with weight categories, like rowing or combat sports, can encourage athletes to engage in extreme measures to “make weight.”
The Continuum of Risk
Disordered eating does not always progress to an eating disorder, but it is a risk factor. Without early recognition and intervention, these behaviours can escalate, leading to more severe outcomes that impact not only mental health but also physical performance and long-term health.
For athletes, untreated disordered eating can result in:
Reduced performance: Inadequate fuelling and nutritional deficiencies can limit endurance, strength, and recovery.
Increased injury risk: Poor nutrition affects bone density, muscle repair, and immune function.
Psychological impacts: Obsessive thoughts about food or weight can detract from focus, confidence, and enjoyment of sport.
Supporting Athletes: Prevention and Intervention
1. Education and Awareness
Educating athletes, coaches, and support staff about the risks of disordered eating and the importance of balanced nutrition is a key step. This includes challenging myths about food and body weight and promoting a holistic view of wellbeing.
2. Recognising the Signs
Early warning signs might include:
Frequent discussions about weight or body shape.
Significant changes in eating patterns or habits.
Avoidance of team meals or social events involving food.
Persistent fatigue, injuries, or illness.
3. Building a Supportive Environment
Create a team culture that values health and performance over appearance. Encouraging open conversations about mental health can help reduce stigma and make it easier for individuals to seek support when needed.
4. Access to Professional Help
Early intervention is critical. Disordered eating behaviours can be addressed through sport psychology interventions, nutrition counselling, and collaboration with medical professionals. For athletes with diagnosed eating disorders, a multidisciplinary approach is essential.
Final Thoughts: A Shared Responsibility
Understanding the differences between disordered eating and eating disorders is vital for anyone involved in sport. Both can compromise an athlete’s mental health, physical performance, and overall wellbeing, but with early recognition and appropriate intervention, these risks can be mitigated.
Creating a culture that prioritises health, balance, and resilience not only supports athletes in reaching their potential but also ensures that their achievements are sustainable and aligned with their long-term health goals.
Need Support?
If you or someone you know is struggling with disordered eating or an eating disorder, reach out to organisations like The Butterfly Foundation in Australia or consult a qualified sport psychologist or dietitian for guidance. Early help makes a significant difference.
Comments